View Full Version: Results show was horrible, and I would say it was staged

realityisland >>American Idol 5 >>Results show was horrible, and I would say it was staged


idolfan- 04-06-2006
Results show was horrible, and I would say it was staged
Whenever they break them into groups, something happens that you never expect. Jennifer, Fantasia, and Latoya... I believe that happened in a group. And a kind of shocking group happened last season too, i think. It seemed too staged to be true... When they put the three groups together, I said "Paris, Mandisa, and Elliot are the bottom 3." because as soon as I say it I thought this is the surprise for this season. And then I freaked because those are 3 of my 4 favorites. Then, Ryan said one was going home, and I freaked again. When he started in on Paris about how she's one of the youngest, etc. etc. I thought he was going to say it was the end, then I was surprised when it was Elliot and Mandisa and I didn't know who to root for. Then, Ryan was like "The person leaving tonight is... Mandisa *pause* you are safe" I was really confused because they had the camera on the families not the stage and I was like what the hell? who went home? Anyway, good luck Mandisa!!! I miss you already. :cry:

pika- 04-06-2006
Re: Results show was horrible, and I would say it was staged
Then, Ryan was like "The person leaving tonight is... Mandisa *pause* you are safe" I was really confused because they had the camera on the families not the stage and I was like what the hell? who went home? I was very confused about that, too. When he said her name, I thought she was the one out. Then he said something to her that I couldn't make out and were showing the families in the audience and I couldn't figure out if he had said she was safe or if she really was out. I'm so ticked that she got voted off for one bad week. There are plenty of other contestants that should have gone before her. I can't stress how much I hate having the audience call in votes for the winner. When it comes down to a popularity contest, you know it's going to be the young, thin, hot ones who stick around while the others are sent home, regardless of their talent. I suppose that happens in real life, too, but it just sucks. :evil:

idolfan- 04-06-2006

My favorite never wins. I was really pissed off too because I can't BELIEVE that Bucky, Kellie, and Ace are still in it over her. Even with three average performances, she should have been easily safe for three more weeks. I really hope Mandisa makes a cd. I'll buy it for sure! I truly believe that if Mandisa was skinny, she would have gotten away with one bad week. Kellie did, didn't she?

Matt- 04-06-2006
Re: Bottom Three Semi-Shocker!
Idolfan, your signature line shows this week's bottom three. Weird, huh? :shock: Eh, I wasn't too surprised with this week's bottom three. Elliot and Paris deserved to be there. It's a shame Taylor wasn't eliminated instead of Mandissa, though. Oh well, at least my three favorite are still alive and kicking: Chris, Bucky, and Kellie.

idolfan- 04-07-2006
Re: Bottom Three Semi-Shocker!
Idolfan, your signature line shows this week's bottom three. Weird, huh? :shock: Wow I didn't notice that!! :shock: I was so mad when Ryan announced the bottom 3. :evil:

La Belle- 04-08-2006

There was a weird silence because of a group of nasty girls yelling and screaming "Goodbye n***ga"

Rufus- 04-10-2006

I tried listening to that tape but didn't hear that, heard a bunch of yelling "oh no" and such, but didn't hear the racial stuff. Anyway, other than Ace going next, I'm not too sure what else should happen. I just love the show and hope there are good discussions going on with this forum because you guys are stick with me for AI!! That is when my computer is loading your forums!!

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.