March 27th Show Discussion
What was the theme of this week's competition? Hits of the 21st century or something like that? Well, whatever it was, it featured some of the worst song selection ever. Half the songs were ones I had never heard before. Ugh. What a terrible night. :roll: Chris was good, even though the song he picked wasn't a good choice. If you were to choose a Creed song, why would you pick "What If?" over the numerous better Creed songs. Chris really let me down with his song selection. But at least he showed that he can made a bad song sound decent. Way to go, Chris. I actually thought Bucky did a decent job with his song choice. It suited him fine. I just don't see what America doesn't see in him, Bucky is so much better than he gets credit for. Lisa deserves to go home this week, her redition of that Kelly Clark song was awful. The other two in the bottom 3 deserve to be Elliot and Ace.

Oh, Matt you're 2 for 3 with that prediction! And spot on with the the Lisa prediction. Do you have 'the gift??' The songs on Tuesday were all one big fat I was surprised to see Katharine in the bottom three, though :shock: I thought she did better then some others.

With the exception of Kelly Clarkson from the very first season, I totally agree! I haven't even cared for the top three in any of the last four seasons. On a seperate rant-I used to love Kelly, but the songs she comes out with get soooo popular that the local radio stations play them literally to death, I get so sick and tired of hearing one of her songs every five minutes, that it's getting to a point where I wish she'd just stop releasing songs for a while

Carrie was good and I thought she deserved to win but she doesn't do the style of music I like. She could be the best country singer the world has ever known and I wouldn't buy her CD.