If you could chose how the final 12 finished...
HOW WOULD YOU HAVE PLACED THEM???? I don't think Taylor was the right one to win, but congrats to him he pulled off a a great finale, as did Katharine. Had you asked me at the start if those would two would be there in the end, I would have told you there was no chance. Here's how I would have placed the Idols, if I could have. American Idol: Chris Daughtry Runner-up: Mandisa 3rd: Elliot 4th: Katharine 5th: Paris 6th: Taylor 7th: Kellie 8th: Lisa 9th: Bucky 10th: Ace 11th: Kevin 12th: Melissa

I'm cool with the way things went.

Re: If It Were Up To Me...
If it had been up to me, here's how things would have gone down: American Idol: Chris Runner-up: Kellie 3rd: Mandisa 4th: Katharine 5th: Bucky 6th: Paris 7th: Taylor 8th: Melissa 9th: Lisa 10th: Elliot 11th: Ace 12th: Kevin