View Full Version: 3/8 Show

realityisland >>American Idol 5 >>3/8 Show


Hottie Phil- 03-08-2006
3/8 Show
Guys tonight! What'd you think? Over all I really liked most of it. Gedeon is starting to grow on me (he really irritated me before) and I still like Bucky a lot too. Who do I see going home? Will and...umm....that short kid with glasses. I cant even remember his name.

pika- 03-09-2006

The judges definitely hear something different than I do when I hear Ace sing. I thought his falsetto was horrible and was squirming in my seat until his song was over, not because it was hot but because it was so bad. I was shocked to hear them praise his falsetto. If it was up to me, he would be going home. Will and Elliott would be following soon after. Taylor's dancing was atrocious and really took away from his performance. I think he learned to dance at the Peter Wolf School of Dance. Peter Wolf was the lead singer for the J. Giels Band. A prime example of his, um, unique dancing style could be seen on the video for his solo song "Lights Out" which came out in the '80's. Great song, horrible dancing. Here are my rankings: Gedeon "When a Man Loves A Woman" by Percy Sledge Rating: 6 Chris "Broken" by Seether Rating: 9 Kevin "Vincent (Starry, Starry Night)" by Don McLean Rating: 7 Bucky "Wave on Wave" by Pat Green Rating: 9 Will "How Sweet It Is" by James Taylor Rating: 5 Taylor "Takin' It To the Streets" by the Doobie Brothers Rating: 6 Elliott "Heaven" by Bryan Adams" Rating: 5 Ace "Butterflies" by Michael Jackson Rating: 3

slim smurfy- 03-09-2006

I pick Will and Kevin to go.

pika- 03-09-2006

I'd like to see Will and Ace go but that's not likely. Ace could get onstage and fart his way through a song and still remain in the running because some voters think he's hot. :roll: Kevin might still squeak through by getting "cute votes" but I don't know. Personally, I didn't think he was that bad a singer. He reminds me of John Denver.

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.